November 16, 2026

MLB’s proposed salary cap and what it means for baseball in 2027

Views: 0
San Diego Padres vs. Milwaukee Brewers in Game 4 of National League Division Series (Oct. 7, 2026). Photo by Lincoln Zdunich

The 2027 Major League Baseball season may start late this year. For the first time since 1994, MLB is pushing for a salary cap system to be implemented in the new Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) between MLB and the Players’ Association (MLBPA). When a cap was pushed for in 1994, it resulted in the loss of the second half of the season and the World Series. This time around, a whole season could be lost. 


It’s pertinent to first explain what a salary cap/floor system is, as well as what it means for professional sports. Since its inception, baseball has never had a cap/floor system in place. Meanwhile, the three other major sports (NFL, NBA and NHL) have a firm system. 

Heading into 2026, the NHL has a hard cap of $104 million per team, the NBA’s is set at $164.9 million and the NFL’s sits at $301.2 million. Each was implemented at various times, with the NHL’s coming in 2004, the NFL’s in 1994 and the NBA’s back in 1983. 

In all three cases, the battle was ugly. The NHL lost the entire 2004-05 season before introducing its cap/floor system. The NFL Players Association was forced to decertify themselves as a union in 1993 before theirs came into effect. The NBA had a slightly better time after the owners ended it by agreeing to share a guaranteed percentage of revenue with players. 

However, a cap/floor system hasn’t fixed any of the major problems. Players in the other leagues are not paid true market value because of the cap system in place. The argument for a cap often used is that this would improve fan experience and costs, but the opposite is true. 

The year before the salary cap system went into effect in the NBA, tickets to a game cost $9.88 on average. Afterward, ticket prices increased a whopping 22.5% ($12.35 average). Inflation accounts for just 4.32% of that jump. It’s the same story in the NFL, with the average cost of a game in 1993 being $28.50. After the cap system was introduced, that number went up 8.3% to roughly $30.87 per ticket (2.83% inflation). 

A study done by the online publication Stadium Journey (2026) found that the average ticket price of an MLB game sits at approximately $34.82. With a percentage increase range of 8.3% to 22.5%, that number could rise anywhere from $2.89 to $7.83. 

The Family Cost Index (FCI) is a measure that indicates the average cost for a family of four to attend a baseball game. According to The Athletic, that figure sat at $253 in 2025. That number could increase to $309.92 (a 22.5% increase), which would price families out of being able to attend baseball games. 

All of this is without mentioning the fact that players wouldn’t be getting paid what they are worth. Currently, NBA, NFL and NHL players are not paid their true market value because of the cap/floor system in place. MLB players, on the other hand, are. If a cap/floor system were introduced to MLB, it would simply take money away from players to give to ownership. That doesn’t fix competitive balance; it lines the pockets of greedy owners. 

One of the major problems facing a potential salary cap has been the recent success of the Los Angeles Dodgers. The Dodgers have been a juggernaut, winning two of the last three World Series championships while spending more than almost any other team. That level of spending has led many to question if winning is a direct result of spending. 

The issue with that argument is that it’s illogical. If anything, spending is more correlative than causative. Of the 22 teams that have made the World Series since 2015 (excluding the 2017 season due to the Houston Astros’ cheating scandal), seven of the clubs were outside the top 10 in payroll. Only two of them have won (Kansas City Royals in 2015, Milwaukee Brewers in 2026). 

That would seem to indicate a lack of competitive balance. The problem is that the postseason is a crapshoot. It’s nearly impossible to win, and payroll has a lot less to do with it than sheer luck does.

When determining competitive balance, it’s more helpful to look at playoff appearances. Since the postseason format expanded to include 12 teams in 2022, 60 clubs have made the playoffs. Of those 60, 30 have been in the top 10 in payroll. 30 organizations outside the top 10 payrolls have clinched a postseason appearance, and 20 inside the top 10 missed the playoffs entirely. 

One would think that the recent World Series matchup between the Milwaukee Brewers (19th in payroll) and the Tampa Bay Rays (28th in payroll) would stop the owners from having any ammunition to use against the MLBPA. Instead, owners have used it as an excuse as to why they don’t need to spend in order to compete. 

The problem with noncompetitive teams often isn’t that they’re getting steamrolled by wealthier organizations, it’s that their owner isn’t willing to spend enough money to field a competitive roster. The average net worth of MLB owners sits at $4.7 billion. So the problem clearly isn’t a lack of funds. The issue is an unwillingness to spend those funds. 

The CBA is set to expire on Dec. 1. Once that happens, free agency will be paused, and a lockout will begin until a CBA is agreed upon between the two parties. If one isn’t reached by Opening Day, games will be lost. 

Players are already set to strike and will wait the owners out as long as they have to. The MLBPA is one of the strongest labor unions in the world, and it has yet to bend the knee to ownership even when the World Series had to be missed. They are unlikely to change that philosophy now.

Author

Related Post